Unforgotten Casebook — One case. Every angle. One place.
← Case library

2005 · Morgantown, West Virginia

James “Jimmy” Michael

A Morgantown fire and the Michelle Michael prosecution

James “Jimmy” Michael died at the couple’s Morgantown home in November 2005. A house fire initially shaped the investigation, but toxicology evidence led investigators to examine a drug his wife, nurse Michelle Michael, could access at work. A jury convicted her of murder and arson in 2007. She maintained her innocence. In 2023, she sought a new trial over her lawyer’s performance. Snapped and John Glatt’s book revisit the evidence and competing accounts.

View timeline →

EXPLORE THE CASE

The Story

Start Here
When2005
WhereMorgantown, West Virginia
In this collection4 resources

Start here.

Choose a book, screen story or audio episode from this case’s collection.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon buttons marked “paid link” may earn us a commission. Affiliate disclosure

Where are they now?

No reviewed items have been added to this section yet.

Nicknames & media names

No reviewed items have been added to this section yet.

EXPLORE THE CASE

Blogs & Essays

The Journal

Read our articles here and explore outside perspectives, credited to their writers and publications. See this case in the Journal →

From the journal

No reviewed items have been added to this section yet.

Blogs & essays

No reviewed items have been added to this section yet.

EXPLORE THE CASE

Books

Read The Story
Explore Free Reading, Previews & Library Options →

CONTINUE YOUR READING

Search this case on Amazon · paid link

Search results may include unrelated titles. Check the author, edition, and case connection before purchasing.

Explore Reading & Streaming Options · Our case guides are free.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon buttons marked “paid link” may earn us a commission. Affiliate disclosure

Books

1 items

John Glatt · St. Martin’s Griffin / Macmillan

Playing With Fire

The publisher identifies Glatt’s nonfiction account of Jimmy Michael’s death and the prosecution of his wife, Michelle, also known as Shelly. This page confirms the book’s author and subject and offers edition information for readers seeking a longer narrative.

BookAccess Varies · Check Source

Link Check PendingReport a Link (Email)

Search Amazon · paid linkExplore this book

Title search; Amazon availability is not confirmed. Check the edition, format, and viewing region.

More Formats & Stores

Choose how you want to read or watch. These are optional paid links.

Links marked “Search” show retailer results. Check the edition, current availability and US region before buying. An Audible link does not guarantee inclusion in a membership. How affiliate links work.

Explore Books, Shows & Movies Connecting Several Cases →

EXPLORE THE CASE

Movies & TV

Documentaries & Adaptations

Movies

No reviewed items have been added to this section yet.

TV & documentaries

1 items
About these sources

Episodes, documentaries and title listings. Season and episode numbers follow the linked catalog and can differ by service. Air dates are separate from crime dates. Playback availability varies by service and region.

Oxygen True Crime · Season 6, Episode 14 · TVmaze listing

Snapped — Michelle Michael

Identifies the Michelle Michael episode covering this case. The season and episode numbers follow TVmaze's listing. Use the companion reporting and records below to distinguish the television account from the documented legal outcome.

Screen TitleAccess Varies · Check Source

Link Check PendingReport a Link (Email)

Search Amazon · paid linkEpisode details on TVmaze

Title search; Amazon availability is not confirmed. Check the edition, format, and viewing region.

More Formats & Stores

Choose how you want to read or watch. These are optional paid links.

Links marked “Search” show retailer results. Check the edition, current availability and US region before buying. An Audible link does not guarantee inclusion in a membership. How affiliate links work.

Episode data: TVmaze · CC BY-SA 4.0

EXPLORE THE CASE

Audiobooks

Listen To The Books

An audiobook edition has not been confirmed for this case yet. You can check the audiobook catalog or explore the case’s podcasts.

Check Audio Formats For This Book

These books are in this case’s collection. An audiobook version has not been verified for the listings below.

Playing With Fire

John Glatt · St. Martin’s Griffin / Macmillan

Search Audiobook Editions · paid link

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon buttons marked “paid link” may earn us a commission. Affiliate disclosure

EXPLORE THE CASE

Fiction Work

Adaptations & Inspirations

Fiction Work

Browse all →

Scripted stories and fictional inspirations. Scenes, characters, and dialogue can differ from the record.

No verified fictional adaptation or inspiration has been identified in this collection. Nonfiction coverage is listed in the other media sections.

EXPLORE THE CASE

Podcasts

Episodes & Audio Stories

Podcasts

No reviewed items have been added to this section yet.

EXPLORE THE CASE

Social Media

Videos & Conversations

BRING YOUR PERSPECTIVE

Where would you start?

Choose your reading route, then share a question with your community.

My first source would be…

Your choice stays on this page. No vote is submitted or counted.

Talk about sources and storytelling with care for the people affected. A documentary, a book and a court record serve different purposes.

Social Media

No reviewed items have been added to this section yet.

EXPLORE THE CASE

News & Reading

Reporting, Clippings & Archives

News & reporting

2 items

Erin Cleavenger · The Dominion Post via Yahoo · August 2023

Michelle Michael’s 2023 retrial request

Local reporting on Michael’s challenge to her representation at trial.

JournalismAccess Varies · Check Source

Link Check PendingReport a Link (Email)

CBS News · 48 Hours · 2008

Death Without Mercy

CBS’s account examines the investigation and trial. Compare this earlier report with the later retrial-request coverage linked here.

JournalismAccess Varies · Check Source

Link Check PendingReport a Link (Email)

Newspaper clippings

0 items

Featured newspaper clipping

No newspaper image has been cleared for display for this case yet. Explore the archive below.

Keep following the newspaper trail.

Search original reporting, follow the trial, and compare how newspapers covered the case over time.

Explore more on Newspapers.com

Newspapers.com controls access to its archive. A subscription may be required; existing subscribers can sign in.

Internet Archive

No reviewed items have been added to this section yet.

EXPLORE THE CASE

Court & Files

Explore The Documents

Court records & documents

0 items
About these sources

Documents are labeled by type and scope. Allegations in filings are not findings of guilt. This collection is not the complete case file.

No accessible court document has been verified for this case yet.

New material will appear here after editorial review.

EXPLORE THE CASE

Positive Outcome

Laws, Advocacy & Change

Positive Outcome

0 items
About these sources

Documented laws, advocacy and reforms. Listing a change does not claim it is effective or universally supported.

No case-specific reform has been verified for this collection yet.